Backchannel hashtag #sxswfinance
Panel:
Mint.com - Patzer
Smartypig - Ferrari
Billeo - Subbarao
Keeping nickels - Stephens
The FI environment does not allow true innovation.
What do you know that banks don't know?
Allow community to talk back and help keep with the changes. Banks
can't engage in an environment where things are fluid.
More ppl need to talk about personal finance on the web. Need to talk
about fees etc.
Young ppl don't know how to budget. List all expenses out. Process
can be tedious. Set budgets in groups 'going out with friends.'.
Complexity is the enemy. Ppl need to be honest with themselves and
what they are spending.
The sooner you can get money from payday to saving accounts, the better.
How do you deal with security?
Banks have a lot of security. They have everything about you and
ability to move your money around. Mint.com is anonymous. They don't
move money around. They send out alerts for suspicious activity.
They have a special area for servers that are tight security.
Smartypig is audited quarterly. They are goverened the same way as a
bank.
Billeo does not keep sensitive data.
Your browser can be compromised.
Why should ppl trust small companies with their finances?
It is anonymous. Seeing account balances is not as scary as leaving
your ATM slip. iPhone connection uses phone database. If it gets
stolen, you go online and wipe it.
To learn about finances?
Since the financial crisis, mint registration tripled.
Ppl are thinking more about their finances. How best to start saving.
What type of functionality do ppl want?
Smarty pig manages goals. Mint is not action oriented enough.
Smarty pig users wanted it integrated into mint. The first step for
ppl is trying to get a feel for it and understand where there money is
going.
Ppl need to look at mint or online account frequently. Help ppl
figure out what money is coming in and what is going out. Ppl need to
stay on top of payment obligations.
If you are doing a good job with your community, then you are doing a
good job.
Incenticise behaviour?
There are opportunities for great innovation here.
The incentive can be environmental or social. Can scam purchases to
track carbon footprint. Mint sees a lot of possibilities.
Gartner did a study and 80-90% did not hear of these online services.
How do you get out?
Smartypig - wanted to ensure sustainability of company without
advertising.
Mint gets a 20% clickthrough rate on targetted ads.
Billeo gets rev from promoting credit card products.
Is there competition outside us?
Mint gets a lot of demand in Canada and the uk. They willbe ecansing
next year.
Smartypig will be expanding in 3-4 international countries next year.
Smartypig already works with a lot of large banks. Mint will not work
with banks.